Notes from Zipporah and Bridegroom of Blood

It may be useful to look over the notes prior to the class on Cushite woman.   In the discussion, some suggested that since God had decreed circumcision with Abraham, Moses was not in compliance and therefore Zipporah needed to circumcise  Moses.  In this view, it was not Gershom who was circumcised.   My notes  contain an alternate view.

Keturah and Midian
Ø      Gen 25:1-2  After death of Sarah, and Rebekkah moves into Isaac’s tent – Moses takes Keturah for wife– one son is Midian.  (nomadic desert tribes) –
Ø      Gen 25:6 sons of Abraham’s concubine (pilagesh) are sent eastward.  (Perhaps Keturah’s sons.).  I Chron 1:32 states “Sons of Keturah, Abraham’s concubine (pilagesh).   Pilagesh is between wife and slave, technically independent, sustained by man, yet free to leave.  (TWC p 125)

Exodus –Jethro and Zipporah
Ø      2:15-22 – Moses flees from Pharoah after killing the Egyptians and goes to the land of Midian.  He marries Zipporah, the daughter of the priest (cohen) of Midian (outside of Egyptian jurisdiction).  First called Reuel.  Look how Moses is a savior, like with the Hebrews.  They have a son named Gershom (“ger” resident alien, no land).  What does Zipporah know from being a priest’s daughter?
·         Per Etz Hayim: early history of close friendly relations between Midianites and Israel – became enemies following conquest of Canaan (see Num 31)
Ø      3:1 – Father in law priest now called Jethro.  Moses tending flocks goes to Horeb (Sinai) and burning bush; mysterious and miraculous Presence.  YGod calls Moses to service, Moses demurs.  —YMagic rod snake;  —Yleprous hand [CUSHITE];  —Ywater turns to blood [ZIPPORAH];  —YAaron to speak [CUSHITE].
Ø      3:20 – So Moses took his wife and sons.
Ø      4:18-20 – Moses takes leave of Jether (Jethro) and Moses heads to Egypt with Zipporah and sons (note plural)
Ø      4:22-3 – Moses to say to pharoah about killing first-born (he never does)
Ø      4:24-26 – the mysterious bridegroom of blood and Zipporah’s evident priestess power.  Echoes of burning bush mysteriousness and blood.
·         Moses’ legs could be genitals.
·         Tosefta Shabbat 15:8 – women can circumcise, but not in Bavli.  See also Cohen.
·         (JSB 113)  the saving power of the bloody foreskin may foreshadow the protective role of blood on the Israelite’s door posts.
·         (Pardes) Interpretations of why God seeks to kill Moses (strictly speaking not clear if Moses or son is intended victim)
o        premonition of things to come re Pharaoh: plague against firstborns;  danger to nation as a whole during last plague
o       variation of theme of Moses refusing call – comes after God’s revelation at bush and Moses’ reluctance
·         (Pardes) Interpretations of Zipporah’s action
o       she placates the attacker and illustrates to Moses that the weak can overcome the strong – and can stick hostile oppressors;  and Moses did seem paralyzed by weakness here.
o       right after this Ex 5, Moses goes to pharoah.
o       she rescues him a bit like Miriam and Pharaoh’s daughter did
·         Note Jacob wrestling with Angel: Gen 32:23-33 for a comparable mysterious encounter with God
·         Etz Hayim: confrontation with God is so terrifying that it makes confrontation with Pharaoh minor.  hatan damim could convey “you are now circumcised and so protected for me by means of the blood of circumcision.”   Shades of protection of pascal lamb blood.

Etz = Etz Hayim
Fischer = Exodus to Deuteronomy A Feminist Companion to the Bible: “The Authority of Miriam,” Imrtraud Fischer
JSB = JPS Study Bible
Nashim = Nashim Spring 2010 Wendy Zierler “On Account of the Cushite Woman that Moses Took”
Pardes = Countertraditions in the Bible

Summer Tanach Studies July 19

Summer Tanach Studies 
Monday, July 19, 2010, 7:30 pm – 8:45 pm 
Eitz Chayim Library
NOTE NEW TIME AND PLACE
Topic is  
The Midianites: Priests?  Monotheists? 
Zipporah, the Cushite Woman, Miriam and Moses
Ex 4:24-26 “The Bridegroom of Blood”
Num 11:35-12:9 “The Cushite Woman” 
And Related Texts 
Please do not bring food as this is the beginning of the fast of Tisha B’av. 
If anyone would like to stay after class and read Eicha (Lamentations) together, we can do so
 



The formation of the Israelites

To those who were in the Canaanite class, thanks for sending me back to check on my comments about the Iron Age being responsible for cisterns and creating terraces. 

Although a huge number of cisterns were required, along with clearing the wilderness and creating the terraces in the settlement in the hills of Palestine in the time of Joshua (about 1200 BCE), the evidence that iron tools made this possible is thin.   What is certain that there was a huge amount of physical labor involved in the settlement, in creating the irrigation systems and the vineyards etc.  Carol Meyers says “The role of the Israelites as inventors of technology is a moot point.  What stands out is the presumably unprecedented and widespread use of cisterns in the pioneer period [time of Joshua circa 1200 BCE]…. The number of implements made of iron in proportion to bronze does not rise significantly in the Iron I period.  Whether iron or bronze tools, the physical effort involved was sustantial.”  Discovering Eve, pg 55.   See also the PBS Nova series “The Secrets of the Bible.” http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/bible/

Texts for Canaanites – from Curse to Conquest

Topic Text Notes














Appearance in Text







Gen 9:20-27 Curse of Canaan by Noah – Ham saw father’s nakedness = ervah ערה



implies shameful exposure – BdB 788




rainbow right before this in text




Adam & Eve nakedness = arumim – Gen 2:25, 3:7,10 – not ashamed ערמ
Who “they” are
exposed – bare




Gen 10:15-10 List of Canaan’s descendents – Jebusites, Amorites, Gergishites, etc

Ex 3:8,17, 34 List of tribes, Canaanites, Hittites, Amorites, Perizzites, Hivites, Jebusites
What is wrong with them?






Lev 18:3,6,7 Do not be like Canaanites – do not uncover ervah – implies act of rape ערה

Lev 18:24-30 do not defile yourselves like them – Canaanites as sexual degenerates.

Lev 20:22-26 do not follow their practices – you shall possess the land











What God will do







Just Land







Gen 12:5 Abram sets forth for Canaan and arrives for a stop


Gen 12:7 God assigns land to Abram’s offspring



Gen 13:12 Abram returns from Egypt andstays in land of Canaan


Gen 13:14-17 God promises Canaan to Abram




Gen 15:7 God gives Canaan as inheritance to Abram



Gen 15:16 Iniquity of Amorites





Gen 15:18-19 God covenants with Abram to give land to offspring


Gen 17:8 God establishes covenenant and gives Canaan and will be also their God

Gen 23:19 Abraham buries Sarah in Canaan



Gen 24:3-4 Isaac cannot have a Canaanite wife



Gen 28:1 Jacob cannot take wife from daughters of Canaan


Gen 31:3 YHVH tells Jacob to return to birthplace – place of ancestors (Canaan)

Gen 33:18 Jacob returns to Canaan




Gen 36:2 Esau took wives from daughters of Canaan



Ex 3:8,17 God will take them to Canaanite land – list of tribal names


Ex 6:8 God will bring them to the land




Ex 33:1-2 I will send an angel to drive out the Canaanites etc


Num 14:9 Joshua says the Canaanites are “our prey”



Num 14:45 they lose battle with Canaanites and Amalekites at Horman

Deut 11:23-25 God will dislodge – put dread and fear over land


Deut 31:3-5 God will cross over before the Israelites and wipe “them” out










Land and not worshipping foreign gods



KEY Ex 23:23-33 You shall not bow down to their gods – I will drive them out – no covenant with them and gods

Ex 34:11-16 God covenants with Moses to drive out Canaanites etc – no covenant with “them”


This is after Golden Calf and 2nd 10.  If they are driven out, 
how can they be covenanted with?

Num 33:51-55 You shall dispossess and demolish – Those you allow to remain will be thorns
see Ex 23:23-33 Bible is severe with Canannites because culture easily confused w/ Isrealites: Torah 1019

Deut 6:10-15 Land full of cities and cisterns you did not make – do not follow their gods

Deut 7:1-5 You must doom them to destruction – not intermarry – smash their pillars Rahav
see Num 33:51-53







KEY Deut 7:16-26 You shall destroy – really strong





Deut 9:1-5 God will wipe them out because of their wickedness



Deut 12: 2-3 Tear down the altars






Deut 12:29-31 God will cut down nations





Deut 20:10-15 Offer peace – kill males and take booty – this is for distant towns


Deut 20:16-18 Towns belonging to Canaanites that are heritage, no one can live. 
Rahav


Proscribe lest they lead you to do things they have done for their gods
Contradictions







Lev 25:44 You may acquire slaves from nations about you


Lev 25:45,47 You may acquire slaves from children or resident aliens
גר

Lev 26:32 God will make land desolate so enemies who settled in will be appalled

Lev 26:38 Land of your enemies shall consume you



Num 15:14-16 Same rules for you and stranger


גר

Num 15:26 Israelite community and stranger alike shall be forgiven 
גר

Num 15:29 One ritual for Israel and stranger


גר

MONDAY, June 21 – Canaanites – from Curse to Conquest

MONDAY, June 21 – Canaanites – from Curse to Conquest
TUESDAY, July 6 – topic tbd
MONDAY, July 19 – topic tbd
MONDAY, August 2 – topic tbd
7:00 pm to 8:30 pm in the Eitz Chayim Community Room
136 Magazine Street, Cambridge
Feel free to bring brown bag dinner and/or wine

Through a close and intertextual reading of selected Biblical texts, we will explore the intersection of gender and politics in the ancient Israelite love/hate relationship with the outsider/other.

Each session will be completely stand-alone. Come to any or all.

Neither prior text study nor knowledge of Hebrew is required. Penina will supply the text choices. Bringing your own tanach (Bible) will be very helpful.

Topics may include
• Moabite women (and Ruth and David) – the permeable boundary between insider and outsider
• The Cushite woman (and Miriam and Moses)
• The Adam and Eve – is Creation in the image of God androgynous? Is YHVH gendered?